This post has been sponsored by Betty Crocker™. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Start a Heartwarming Tradition: DIY ‘You’ve Been Treated’ Gifts with Betty Crocker Cookie Cups
In a world that often feels disconnected, finding ways to foster community and spread joy among those around us is more important than ever. This year, I invite you to join me in starting a delightful new tradition: surprising your neighbors and friends with thoughtful “You’ve Been Treated” gifts. These easy-to-assemble packages, complete with free printable instructions and tags, are the perfect way to show appreciation and create lasting bonds. Get ready to brighten someone’s day with a touch of homemade kindness!

I recently embarked on creating these charming DIY “You’ve Been Treated” bags, specifically designed to delight our wonderful new neighbors. As the “new kids on the block,” we’ve been overwhelmed by their warmth and generosity, and I wanted to find a unique way to express our gratitude. Inside these special bags, I’ve included an assortment of Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cups, along with a few carefully chosen extra treats to make the surprise even more memorable.
The Inspiration: A Community’s Welcome and a Desire to Pay It Forward
The genesis of this heartwarming project has a beautiful backstory. Our family recently moved into a new neighborhood, and from the moment we arrived, we’ve been embraced with open arms. It has been a truly wonderful experience for all of us – from shared backyard barbecues and lively ball game viewings to our children playing together until the last rays of sunlight fade. This sense of belonging has quickly made our new house feel like home.
Just the other evening, an unexpected ring at our doorbell at 8 PM piqued our curiosity. “Who could it be at this hour?” I wondered aloud. My son, ever the eager explorer, dashed to the door. To our surprise, no one was there. Instead, resting on our doorstep was a vibrant orange bag, adorned with the playful words, “You’ve Been Booed.”
Discovering that bag filled me with an unexpected wave of pure joy. It was such a delightful and thoughtful gesture, something we had never experienced before. This simple act of kindness, a playful tradition new to us, served as yet another powerful testament to how incredibly happy and welcomed we feel in our new community. The bag was brimming with an array of treats and goodies, perfect for all of us to enjoy together.

That moment sparked an idea. I wanted to perpetuate this wonderful tradition of surprising others, but not just limit it to seasonal events like “You’ve Been Booed” for Halloween, “You’ve Been Elfed” for Christmas, or “You’ve Been Egged” for Easter. My vision was to create a tradition that could bring unexpected joy during those “in-between” times of the year, spreading cheer simply because it’s a nice thing to do, regardless of the calendar.
And so, the concept for these “Happy Fall You’ve Been Treated” kits was born. For the centerpiece of these gifts, I decided to incorporate Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cups – a choice that proved to be both delicious and incredibly convenient. Their ease of preparation and delightful taste make them the perfect treat to share.

Crafting Kindness: Your Step-by-Step Guide to DIY Treat Bags
Ready to embark on your own mission of spreading joy? Here’s a detailed, easy-to-follow guide on how you can create these wonderful DIY “You’ve Been Treated” bags yourself. This project is not just about making treats; it’s about creating an experience, both for the giver and the receiver.
Step 1: Your Sweet Shopping Adventure at Meijer
Your journey begins with a trip to your local Meijer store. Head straight to the baking aisle, a treasure trove of possibilities for your delicious gifts. Meijer offers a fantastic selection, making it easy to find everything you need in one convenient stop.

Step 2: Selecting Your Betty Crocker Cookie Cup Varieties
While in the baking aisle, be sure to pick up a few varieties of Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cups. These convenient kits come with everything you need for delicious, homemade-tasting cookies with minimal effort. I highly recommend trying these irresistible flavors:
- Betty Crocker™ Chocolate Chip Fudge Cookie Cups
- Betty Crocker™ Chocolate Fudge Cookie Cups
- Betty Crocker™ Peanut Butter Fudge Cookie Cups
Each variety offers a unique and satisfying taste, ensuring there’s something everyone will love in your treat bags.
Step 3: Family Fun in the Kitchen – Let the Baking Begin!
Once you have your Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cups, it’s time for the most enjoyable part: baking! Gather your family, especially the little ones, and head to the kitchen. These cookie cups are incredibly simple to make, requiring just a few additional ingredients like butter and water. The process is straightforward, making it a perfect activity for children to participate in. The laughter, the sweet aromas filling your home, and the shared experience of creating something delicious together are truly priceless. It’s not just baking; it’s creating cherished memories.

Step 4: Preparing Your Printable Tags and Notes
While your cookies are baking or cooling, print out the complimentary “You’ve Been Treated” tags and accompanying notes. These printables are designed to add a professional and personal touch to your gift bags, making it easy for recipients to understand the tradition and feel truly appreciated. They explain the concept of paying kindness forward, encouraging a ripple effect of good deeds in your community. You can find these free printable resources easily online or create your own with a similar message.


Step 5: Gathering Your Assembly Supplies
Before you begin assembling, ensure you have all your supplies ready. This organized approach will make the process smooth and enjoyable. You’ll need:
- Gift bags (festive or neutral, depending on the season)
- Smaller cookie bags or cellophane wrappers for individual treats
- A hole punch for attaching tags
- Decorative string or ribbon
- Tissue paper for cushioning and aesthetic appeal
Having everything laid out makes the assembly process efficient and fun, especially if you have little helpers involved!

Step 6: Decorating Your Delicious Cookie Cups
Once your Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cups have cooled, it’s time for the creative touch! Each kit comes with frosting and toppings, allowing you to easily decorate your cookies. This step is particularly enjoyable for kids, who can add sprinkles, drizzles, or other fun embellishments to make each cookie unique. Allow the decorations to set properly before packaging to maintain their pristine appearance.
Step 7: Thoughtful Packaging of Your Treats
Carefully place your decorated cookie cups into the smaller cookie bags or cellophane wrappers. Tie them securely with a bit of string or ribbon, then attach the “Baked with Love” free printable tag. This adds an extra layer of warmth and personalization. Next, place these individually packaged cookie bags into the larger gift bag. Don’t forget to include the main “You’ve Been Treated” sign and instructions so your neighbors understand the delightful tradition you’re initiating.

Step 8: Adding Personal Touches and Extra Delights
To make your “You’ve Been Treated” bags even more special and tailored, consider adding a few extra items that you believe your neighbors, friends, or family might enjoy. This is where you can truly personalize the gift. For example, during my Meijer shopping trip, I picked up a lovely coffee mug and a cute dish towel that I thought would be perfect additions. I also found adorable pumpkin-themed treat bags there, which perfectly complemented the fall theme of my kits. These small, thoughtful additions can elevate your gift from simply a treat to a truly memorable gesture.

Why Betty Crocker Cookie Cups are the Perfect Choice
These Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cup kits are a true game-changer for anyone looking to create delicious homemade treats with ease. Each kit thoughtfully includes the cookie mix, frosting, delightful toppings, and even paper baking cups, making the entire process incredibly convenient. All you need to add are butter and water, and you’re well on your way to baking perfection. They are not only simple to prepare but also provide a wonderfully fun activity, especially for baking with children. The joy of creating these treats together becomes part of the gift itself.
My daughter absolutely loved helping me bake and prepare these special bags for our neighbors. It was a wonderful bonding experience, filled with laughter and the sweet anticipation of surprising others. The simplicity of the Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cups meant we could focus more on the fun of the activity and less on complicated recipes.

Spreading Smiles and Inspiring a Ripple of Kindness
My greatest hope is that these “You’ve Been Treated” bags bring as much joy and as many smiles to your neighbors’ faces as they did to my family’s. There’s something truly magical about an unexpected act of kindness that brightens someone’s day.
Furthermore, I sincerely hope this inspires you to embrace and start a new, fun tradition of gifting loved ones and community members with delicious cookie cups and an abundance of good cheer. It’s a simple gesture that can cultivate stronger community ties, foster a sense of belonging, and remind everyone that they are valued and appreciated. Let’s create a chain reaction of thoughtfulness, one “You’ve Been Treated” bag at a time!
Ready to start your own tradition? Shop now at Meijer and pick up your Betty Crocker™ Cookie Cups today!

